November 19, 2026
Bahamian brokers told The Tribune in late October that their sales and transaction volumes for 2026 to date were up 18 to 20 percent. At Corcoran C.A. Christie, the gain came entirely from price. Gavin Christie said his firm's total sales were up about 18 percent from the same period in 2025, while its transaction count was down about 6 percent and its average sale price was up 18 to 20 percent. Matt Sweeting, managing broker at REMAX Bahamas, told the same paper that 2026's average sales price was up $100,000 year over year while new inventory was down.
When the number of sales drops and a few very expensive homes close, the average can rise a long way even if most individual houses are worth about what they were a year ago. In the Bahamas this year, two separate forces are pushing the figure up. One is a run of branded resort residences priced in the eight figures. The other is a real shortage of resale homes in Nassau's established enclaves. Only the second tells a buyer much about what a comparable house will cost next spring. A buyer comparing Abaco with Exuma on averages is mostly comparing which homes happened to sell on each island.
The clearest example comes from Exuma. Morley Realty's analysis of third-quarter 2026 data from the Bahamas Real Estate Association's MLS, summarized by The Tribune, found that Exuma "saw a sharp increase in average and median home prices." The firm added that the jump "may have been influenced by a smaller number of high-value sales."
The rest of the island's figures point the same way. Exuma's contracted home sales in the third quarter were unchanged from a year earlier. Completed home sales were also flat year over year, though up sharply from the second quarter. Exuma land prices were lower than in the third quarter of 2025, while land listings stayed above the prior year's level. So Exuma had the same number of deals, more land for sale, cheaper land, and much higher average and median home prices. That combination points to a few large closings in a small sample.
In a market this thin, even the median moves when a few large homes close. Morley Realty said as much about land across the islands, describing the swings as "showing how much pricing can move when fewer sales take place."
The measures that held steady describe Exuma's market more reliably. Third-quarter homes on Exuma sold faster than in the second quarter, and sellers there got more than 90 percent of their asking price. Those figures describe ordinary transactions, and they show a market that was active and priced near asking.
Exuma's hospitality pipeline helps explain where high-value buyers are looking. The Bahamas Ministry of Tourism announced in early November that Baymahni had opened on Stocking Island, on the former Kahari property. Baymahni's residence offering lists villas from $1.8 million in materials dated December 2024. Farther up the cays, Rosewood plans a 33-suite private-island resort for 2028. That plan has no homes for sale. As of a Tribune report on November 11, a challenge to its planning approval had not been decided.
Christie gave branded residences much of the credit for the high end's strength, calling them "the new big in luxury real estate that buyers are gravitating to." He expects more of them in the Bahamas over the next three to ten years. The prices on these projects show why a few closings can move an island's numbers.
On Paradise Island, the Ocean Club, Four Seasons Residences is being built on a site overlooking Cabbage Beach. ZNS reported a groundbreaking on January 20, 2025, with 67 homes in four beachfront buildings and completion planned for 2028. When the project was announced in January 2024, The Tribune reported prices from $6.5 million to $23 million. In June 2026, Caribbean Journal reported a five-bedroom beach villa marketed at nearly $23.3 million. The development planned only two beach villas. Citing a November 9 update from the project's representatives, Caribbean Journal reported that Beach Villa 111 was the last one still available.
In the Abacos, Montage Cay is a 53-acre private island less than a mile from Marsh Harbour, developed by Montage International with Sterling Global Financial. As of a March 31, 2026 report in Resident, the project had reached $150 million in sales. Residences start at $4.6 million across seven oceanfront enclaves, and the new four-bedroom Marina Villas start at $9 million. A few closings at those prices can lift Abaco's average in any quarter they land. In the third quarter, Morley Realty reported Abaco home prices above last year but down from the second quarter. Abaco was also the only one of the five major islands where sellers got less than 88 percent of asking. So the island with one of the country's most visible branded projects also had the widest gap between asking and sale prices on ordinary homes. The two sets of figures are measuring different markets.
In Nassau, the Rosewood at Baha Mar is taking ownership inquiries for its residences, which give owners access to hotel services. It does not publish prices.
Lifting the average is only one effect of the shortage. In Nassau's established communities, scarcity is raising what comparable homes sell for. John Christie, president of HG Christie, told The Tribune that "You go into Sandyport and there's hardly anything for sale. Lyford Cay, Old Fort Bay, there's very little for sale." He called it "definitely a seller's market in the higher end communities in New Providence," and expects lack of inventory to be the biggest problem going into the new year.
The island-wide MLS data supports him. In the third quarter of 2026, New Providence sellers got an average of 93.6 percent of asking. Homes there sold in 87 days on average, 45.6 percent faster than in the second quarter. New home listings on the island fell 10.9 percent from the second quarter. New land listings were down 24.2 percent from the third quarter of 2025. Even so, New Providence's average home price rose in the third quarter while its median slipped slightly. The average climbed while the typical sale held about level.
Sweeting's advice to buyers is that "waiting costs money." He says a property a buyer passes on today can cost about 10 percent more a year later. That warning fits best in places like Lyford Cay and Old Fort Bay, where few homes come up for sale and comparable houses compete for the same buyers. It fits less well on an island whose headline price moved because two or three exceptional homes closed in one quarter.
Several dates matter for a buyer planning this winter. HG Christie's John Christie said the market had been quieter in the weeks before the US midterm elections in early November. Gavin Christie said the first quarter is typically the Bahamian market's strongest. Laura Morley of Morley Realty expects the last two months of the year and the start of 2027 to be slower, adding that slower "doesn't mean people will stop looking."
Access to Exuma improves in the same window. The Ministry of Tourism says American Airlines will run three daily nonstop flights between Miami and Exuma International Airport from December 17, 2026 through April 5, 2027. That schedule covers the whole first quarter, the period Christie described as typically the strongest.
Are Bahamian home prices rising in 2026? In the scarce enclaves of New Providence, yes. Sellers there got 93.6 percent of asking in the third quarter of 2026, and listings are thin. Island-wide averages are also lifted by fewer, larger sales. For a fair island-by-island comparison, look at median price, list-to-sale ratio and days on market alongside the average.
Why did Exuma's prices rise so much in the third quarter? Morley Realty linked the jump to a small number of high-value sales. In the same quarter, Exuma's contracted and completed home sales were flat year over year and its land prices fell.
Do branded residences set the price of nearby homes? They set the top of the range and pull up the averages. On Abaco in the third quarter of 2026, the gap between asking and sale prices on ordinary homes was wider than on any other major island, even with Montage Cay's high prices nearby.
Island averages from a handful of sales are a starting point, and the price of a particular house comes from the comparable homes around it. Peter Kempf International can walk you through which recent sales on Paradise Island, Abaco or Exuma are true comparisons for the home you have in mind, and which belong to a different market. To begin that conversation discreetly, request private access to listings.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
I pride myself in providing personalized solutions that bring my clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact me today to find out how I can be of assistance to you!